Sunday, January 15, 2012

off the rails

The Government of the UK is supposed to represent the people. Naïve maybe, but true none the less. It is hard to imagine a Government action, even one from the current bunch of detached, self-centred, let-them-eat-cake multi-millionaires, that flies so hard in the face of the wishes of the people. There is no prejudice here for or against any political party; Labour announced it and ToryLib have progressed it; they are all much the same and all to blame.

Overwhelmingly, the public has said that a high speed railway, known as HS2, from London to Birmingham, and later beyond, is not only unwanted but will be literally disastrous for quality of life, for the countryside and for historic buildings. It is a nonsense, a pointlessness, a fatuity, a mindlessness, an inanity and a bad dream come true. An expensive disaster too, currently predicted by the government to cost £32 billion but we all know it will be in excess of £50 billion and I would bet it will be over £60 billion. Nearly a billion has already been spent on public relations and other forms of fluffiness, a lot of it entirely needlessly because it was always the plan to ignore the outcome of the so-called 'consultation'.

This colossal folly isn’t about business people desperately needing to arrive in another city a little earlier or about the creation of jobs (in fact many will be lost as a result). No business has offered to play any part in the funding of the HS2 white elephant, partly because most businesses know there is no economic benefit to be gained from it for them or for the country. Any attempt by the government, particularly by the poor excuse for a Transport Minister, the hypocritical Justine Greening, to detail any benefit of HS2 is rightly greeted by those without a political motivation with closing of eyes and shaking of head in disbelief at its lack of substance, reality and vision.

Apart from enabling bankers and their like in Birmingham to join their London colleagues for a three hour lunch and get back in time for their 5pm finish and trip to the local wine bar, HS2 will do nothing for the less rich and more human members of society who will pay for it but be priced out of ever using it. HS2 is purely and simply about posturing, bravado, affectation and self-importance.

It’s about a show-off prime minister and his show-off cabinet showing off to France and Germany that the Brits can install a high-tech piece of transport infrastructure, regardless of its lack of merit. But this country is a fraction of the size of those countries, with our major cities relatively easily and quickly accessible without having to ruin lives, nature and architecture.

Of course there is room for huge improvement but that can be achieved through other less draconian measures, as the government knows very well and was so embarrassed to reveal that it concealed the report they commissioned which shows that the alternative 51m proposal offers greater benefit than HS2 at much lower cost.

In a time of austerity when important public services are being starved of money, HS2 is such a monstrous, irrational and destructive waste that it would sit more comfortably as a scene in Gormenghast than as a part of a rational transport policy. Meanwhile our roads will remain pot-holed and our local, rural train services the shambles that they are now.

What happened to the ‘green’ strategy that encouraged people to travel less frequently and promoted the use of technology like video-conferencing to conduct business meetings, many of which are not worth the cost and time to travel to anyway. It has been derailed by MPs who make so many journeys between their second and third homes and on unnecessary foreign trips that their carbon footprints nearly match their oversized egos.

Daft, destructive and divisive, HS2 takes profligacy and recklessness to a new dimension. The battle to stop it must continue.



At January 15, 2012 9:25 pm , Anonymous Anonymous said...


At January 16, 2012 8:44 pm , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, clearly we know what part of the country you live in !

At January 16, 2012 11:34 pm , Blogger call it justice said...

You may or you may not know. But my post would be exactly the same wherever I lived. My objections to HS2 would still stand. It is not me I am thinking about.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home